Committee for Agriculture, Enviroment and Rural Affairs - Policy/Scrutiny

Independent Panel for Review of Decisions

At it's meeting of 28 January 2021 the Committee agreed to request oral and written evidence from a small number of stakeholders on the issue of the Independent Panel of Review of Decisions review.

The Committee considered the evidence and at it's meeting of 25 March agreed to write to the Minister Poots outlining the Committees position on the Review of Independent Panel on Review of Decisions, the Ministers response will also be published in due course.

The following invitation for oral/written evidence was issued to stakeholders and the responses received are listed below along with a Research and Information Service (RaISe) breifing paper commissioned by the Committee.

• Invitation to give oral/written evidence
• ACA NI written submission - Independent Panel for Review of Decision on Area-based Schemes (PDF, 9 pages, 4.13KB)
• Barnwell Farms - Written submission from Barnwell Farms directors to the Committee on their independent stage 2 panel mini enquiry (PDF, 2 pages, 361KB)
• Farmers For Action - Briefing paper (PDF, 2 pages, 194KB)
• Little and O'Brien - briefing paper (PDF, 199 pages, 23.5MB)
• Little O'Brien - Supplementary submission to DAERA Assembly Committee 18 March 2021 (PDF, 13 pages, 1.2MB)
  
• NIAPA written submission - Independent Panel for Review of Decision on Area-based Schemes (PDF, 2 pages, 101KB)
• NI Farm Groups - briefing paper (PDF, 2 pages, 214KB)
• UFU response - review of decisions on area based schemes (PDF, 2 pages, 250KB)
• RaISe paper - Comparison of CAP review of decisions and appeals procedures - UK and Republic of Ireland (PDF, 20 pages, 379KB)

At its meeting of 25 March the Committee agreed the following correspondence to the Minister regarding the Committee position on the Review of Independent Panel on Review of Decisions, the Ministers response will also be published in due course.

• Letter Minister Poots - Committee position on on the Review of Independent Panel on Review of Decisions (PDF, 11 pages, 240KB

At its meeting of 29 April 2021 the Committee considered the following response from Minister Poots to Committee recommendations on the Review of Independent Panel on Review of Decisions.

• Ministerial response to Committee proposals (PDF, 2 pages, 307 KB)