| Membership | What's Happening | Committees | Publications | Assembly Commission | General Info | Job Opportunities | Help |
|
Written Answers to Questions Friday 18 January 2002 Agriculture and Rural Development Agriculture and Rural Development Brucellosis : Claims Mr Gerry McHugh asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to detail (a) the number of claims for Brucellosis in the last 5 years; and (b) how many of these claims were found to be fraudulent. (AQW 1192/01) The Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development (Ms Rodgers): (a) In the last five years the number of Brucellosis cases were as follows:- 1997 – 29 1998 – 62 1999 – 155 2000 – 210 2001 – 187 (b) No prosecutions have been undertaken to date but a number of cases are currently being investigated and compensation is being withheld in 9 cases where irregularities have been identified. Genetically Modified Food Mr Jim Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to outline (a) how many genetically modified food experiments have taken place in the last 2 years; and (b) the impact on surrounding farmland. (AQW 1202/01) Ms Rodgers: There have been no genetically modified food experiments carried out in the last two years in Northern Ireland. As no genetically modified food experiments have been carried out in the last two years in Northern Ireland there has, as a consequence, been no impact on farmland or the environment. Rural Development Programme for 2001-2006 Mr Peter Weir asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to detail what current and future measures are available for the Unionist community to participate in rural development projects. (AQW 1222/01) Ms Rodgers: All measures of the Rural Development Programme for 2001-2006 are, and will continue to be available for the entire rural population, irrespective of community background. The Programme will endeavour to promote equality of opportunity within the section 75 categories. The promotion of equality and inclusion are guiding principles of the Programme and for this reason a commitment to equality will be a key criteria for selection of all projects. The capacity building element of the Programme aims to strengthen areas of weak community infra-structure and to develop diverse and representative community-based organisations in rural areas. This will include a PEACE II measure focused on isolated, minority communities along both sides of the border to involve them in rural regeneration activities. Payment of Lights Dues Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to detail what plans she has to abolish the payment of Light Dues. (AQW 1224/01) Ms Rodgers: Responsibility for policy relating to the payment of lights dues lies with the Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions (DTLR) in London. While I remain fully committed to obtaining the reduction or removal of the payment of lights dues for Northern Ireland fishermen, the policy in the UK is that any removal or reduction of lights dues would be contrary to the "user pays" principle and that, as users of aids to navigation, lights dues are a proper charge against fishermen. However a review of the current structure of UK lights dues is due to be carried out by DTLR in early 2002 and the views of the maritime industry on the current charging regime will be sought. At that stage I will take the opportunity to request that the current economic circumstances of the fishing industry are taken into account when determining the outcome of the review. NI Fishery Harbour Authority : Development Projects Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to outline (a) her commitment to grant aid the Northern Ireland Fishery Harbour's authority for capital works; and (b) the timescale for the completion of these works; and to make a statement. (AQW 1237/01) Ms Rodgers: In addition to the Kilkeel Integrated Development Plan, the Northern Ireland Fishery Harbour Authority have put forward a number of additional development projects at Portavogie, Ardglass and Kilkeel. Currently discussions are taking place with the Harbour Authority on these additional projects in relation to their funding and prioritisation and timescale. Plankton Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to detail (a) the fall in plankton in the Irish Sea over the past 5 years; and (b) the emergence of new forms of copepods off the south coast of Ireland, and in the Bristol and English Channels. (AQW 1238/01) Ms Rodgers: I am not aware of any decrease in the amount of plankton in the Irish Sea over the past 5 years. Information available would confirm, at least in the English Channel, the appearance of new species of copepods in the English Channel over the last few years. Larne Harbour Ltd Mr Roy Beggs asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development, pursuant to AQW 1050/01, what advice she has given to Larne Harbour Ltd to reopen the pedestrian gate at Chaine Memorial Road, Larne, following the review carried out on 3 December 2001. (AQW 1253/01) Ms Rodgers: In March 2001, as a result of the outbreak of Foot and Mouth Disease, my Department asked for the pedestrian gate at Chaine Memorial Road, Larne, to be closed as a FMD precaution. In early December 2001 we further advised Larne Harbour Ltd that, as the FMD situation had improved, we would be content for this gate to be re-opened. Fishing Vessel Decommissioning Scheme Mr Jim Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to outline any financial help for the fishing industry in light of new fishing quotas set by the European Union. (AQW 1300/01) Ms Rodgers: To assist the industry I announced a Fishing Vessel Decommissioning Scheme in October last year and Letters of Offer have now issued to the owners of 34 fishing vessels. More recently I announced the opening of grant applications for schemes aimed at the Improvement of Facilities at Northern Ireland Fishing Ports, Aquaculture, Processing and Marketing of Freshwater and Marine Products and Promotion of Fishery Productions. I would add that at Council increases above last year’s levels were obtained in the Total Allowable Catches for such stocks as Irish Sea cod, Irish Sea plaice and hake. Moreover whilst there was some reduction in the Total Allowable Catch for the important nephrops stocks, this has to be set against the initial Commission’s proposal for a 25% reduction in their reticence for any increase because of their view that the by catch in this fishery includes stocks under threat, for example cod and whiting. The agreed nephrops TAC of 17,790 tonnes still gives the UK a quota which exceeds 2000 landing and likely landings in 2001. Hospitality : December 2001 Mr David Hilditch asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure to detail (a) the cost of and (b) to whom he is providing hospitality during the month of December 2001. (AQW 1107/01) The Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure (Mr McGimpsey): The estimated cost of hospitality during December 2001 was £1,018.23. This figure is broken down as follows: £575.20 - meetings/lunches with Department officials and local representatives. £443.03 - DCAL reception. Interpretative Facilities : East Londonderry Mr David McClarty asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what plans he has to improve cultural interpretative facilities within East Londonderry. (AQW 1125/01) Mr McGimpsey: I have no direct responsibility for the quality of cultural interpretative facilities. However, my Department seeks to work, mainly through the Northern Ireland Museums Council, with local councils, which provide most such facilities, and with others, to ensure that they receive the advice and support they need in carrying out their responsibilities in this regard. My Department has established a Cultural Forum to bring together local councils with a range of other relevant public bodies; this has already provided guidance to councils in the preparation of their cultural strategies. In addition, the Local Museum and Heritage Review will provide another, complementary context for addressing the issue of cultural interpretative facilities. Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission Mr Jim Shannon asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what steps is he taking to promote Ulster-Scots representation within the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission. (AQW 1126/01) Mr McGimpsey: My Department has no role in making appointments to the Commission, which are a matter for the Secretary of State. The Northern Ireland Act states that as far as practicable, the Commissioners, as a group, should be representative of the community in Northern Ireland. Waterways Ireland Mr David Hilditch asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure to detail the cost of the consultancy work contracted to manage the recruitment process of the administration and technical posts at Waterways Ireland. (AQW 1203/01) Mr McGimpsey: The issue referred to by the Member is now a matter for Waterways Ireland, the North/South Implementation Body for Inland Waterways. Waterways Ireland has the functions of management, maintenance, development and restoration of certain inland navigable waterway systems throughout the island, principally for recreational purposes. I understand from Waterways Ireland that two separate recruitment consultancy contracts have been awarded; one for filling outstanding administration and technical posts up to Director level and the other for filling four Director posts. As both these contracts are still in progress, no consultancy costs are yet available. 50 Metre Swimming Pool : University of Ulster, Jordanstown Mr Ken Robinson asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure, pursuant to AQO 449/01, what steps he will take to ensure that a 50 metre swimming pool will form the core of the proposed Centre of Excellence at the University of Ulster, Jordanstown, and act as a magnet for prestige international sporting events. (AQW 1259/01) Mr McGimpsey: As I explained in my answer to AQO 449/01, current plans are to provide a 50 metre swimming pool at the University of Ulster, Jordanstown for the training of international performers as part of the Sports Institute for Northern Ireland (SINI). This will allow for high level training and low level gala promotions. While no spectator provision is specifically included, there will be the potential for a 200-300 temporary seating arrangement for low key events. This satisfies the requirements of the SINI and is expected to cost in the region of £3-4m. I understand the additional cost of upgrading the proposed facility to a 50 metre competition pool, with 8 lanes, boom and spectator accommodation for a minimum of 500 would be at least £3m. Apart from the cost consideration, the need/demand and location for such a facility would have to be carefully assessed and this would be a matter in the first instance for the Sports Council, possibly in partnership with a district council. 50 Metre Swimming Pool : University of Ulster, Jordanstown Mr Ken Robinson asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure, pursuant to AQO 449/01, what steps he will take to encourage the inclusion of adequate spectator accommodation in any scheme for a 50 metre pool in the proposed Centre of Excellence at the University of Ulster, Jordanstown. (AQW 1260/01) Mr McGimpsey: As I explained in my answer to AQO 449/01, current plans are to provide a 50 metre swimming pool at the University of Ulster, Jordanstown for the training of international performers as part of the Sports Institute for Northern Ireland (SINI). This will allow for high level training and low level gala promotions. While no spectator provision is specifically included, there will be the potential for a 200-300 temporary seating arrangement for low key events. This satisfies the requirements of the SINI and is expected to cost in the region of £3-4m. I understand the additional cost of upgrading the proposed facility to a 50 metre competition pool, with 8 lanes, boom and spectator accommodation for a minimum of 500 would be at least £3m.
Apart from the cost consideration, the need/demand and location for such a facility would have to be carefully assessed and this would be a matter in the first instance for the Sports Council, possibly in partnership with a district council. Money Allocated for Gaelic Games Mr Peter Weir asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure how much money was allocated for Gaelic games in each of the last three years. (AQW 1338/01) Mr McGimpsey: The position is as follows:
Action on Autism Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Education to indicate (a) when will the new Centre of Excellence for Action on Autism be completed; and (b) how much funding is being set aside for this project. (AQW 1119/01) The Minister of Education (Mr McGuinness): It is not planned that the proposed Centre of Excellence for the education of children with Autistic Spectrum Disorders will require a new building. Existing premises are being considered for purchase, subject to satisfactory surveys and the subsequent successful conclusion of negotiations with the current owners. My Department made a successful bid to the Executive Programme Funds for additional funding of £110k in 2002/03 and £1.61m in 2003/04 to take forward this project on a North-South basis. The allocation is subject to DFP clearance of an appropriate economic appraisal. As soon as the economic appraisal is cleared, and my Department and the Department of Education and Science have concluded negotiations, I will be in a position to give full details of the location of the Centre and plans for its use. Action on Autism Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Education to indicate (a) when building will commence on the new Centre of Excellence for Action on Autism; and (b) where this Centre will be based. (AQW 1120/01) Mr McGuinness: It is not planned that the proposed Centre of Excellence for the education of children with Autistic Spectrum Disorders will require a new building. Existing premises are being considered for purchase, subject to satisfactory surveys and the subsequent successful conclusion of negotiations with the current owners. My Department made a successful bid to the Executive Programme Funds for additional funding of £110k in 2002/03 and £1.61m in 2003/04 to take forward this project on a North-South basis. The allocation is subject to DFP clearance of an appropriate economic appraisal. As soon as the economic appraisal is cleared, and my Department and the Department of Education and Science have concluded negotiations, I will be in a position to give full details of the location of the Centre and plans for its use. School Closure Mr Mark Robinson asked the Minister of Education to list, by name and location, those schools that were closed in each of the past 5 years. (AQW 1150/01) Mr McGuinness: The following schools were closed or amalgamated in the last 5 years. Those which were amalgamated, are denoted with an asterisk. NAME OF SCHOOL LOCATION School Year 2001/02 Ballymena Academy Prep Department Ballymena *Cambridge House Boys’ Grammar Ballymena *Cambridge House Girls’ Grammar Ballymena Cavanacaw Primary Omagh *Coleraine Boys’ High Coleraine *Coleraine Girls’ High Coleraine Jaffe Special Belfast Glenagoorland Primary Strabane St Anthony’s Primary Belfast *St Mary’s Boys’ Primary Newcastle *St Mary’s Girls’ Primary Newcastle *St Michael’s Primary Enniskillen *St Theresa’s Primary Enniskillen School Year 2000/01 *Croreagh Primary nr Rathfriland *Edendale Primary nr Rathfriland *Glaskermore Primary nr Rathfriland *Holy Trinity Boys’ Primary Belfast *Holy Trinity Girls’ Primary Belfast Rainey Endowed Prep Department Magherafelt Sacred Heart Primary Lurgan *St Mary’s Primary Belfast *St Paul’s Primary Belfast *Gransha Boys’ High Bangor *Bangor Girls’ High Bangor St Joseph’s Centre Middletown St Stephen’s Centre Belfast School Year 1999/2000
*Ballyward Primary nr Banbridge *Ballyroney Primary nr Banbridge *Katesbridge Primary nr Banbridge *Cargycroy Primary nr Lisburn *Legacurry Primary nr Lisburn *Magheraknock Primary nr Lisburn *Ravarnette nr Lisburn Dunamuggy Primary Ballyclare *Glassdrummond Primary Middletown *Middletown Primary Middletown *St Louis Primary Middletown
Larne Grammar Prep Department Larne Millbrook Primary Larne Royal School Dungannon Prep Department Dungannon *St Comgall’s Primary Divis Street, Belfast *St Joseph’s Primary Divis Street, Belfast *St Mary’s Primary Divis Street, Belfast *St Peter’s Primary Divis Street, Belfast School Year 1998/99 *Antrim High Antrim *Ardnaveigh High Antrim Ballyclare Grammar Prep Department Ballyclare *Fernhill Primary Belfast *Glencairn Primary Belfast Killyrammer Primary Ballymoney *Lurganachone Primary Rathfriland *St Colman’s Primary Drumgreenagh Scrabo High Newtownards Star of the Sea Primary Kilkeel *St Clare’s Primary Keady *St Mary’s Primary Keady St Oliver Plunkett Boys’ Primary Belfast *St Oliver Plunkett Girls’ Primary Belfast *Tullymore Primary Armagh *Tullysaran Primary Armagh School Year 1997/98 *Carnew Primary Dromore *Gransha Primary Dromore *Kinallen Primary Dromore Transformation of Schools Mr Ken Robinson asked the Minister of Education to detail the benefits in (a) staffing complement; (b) staffing costs; (c) capital costs; (d) maintenance costs; and (e) education provision, for schools seeking to change their status from controlled to maintained integrated status; and to make a statement. (AQW 1236/01) Mr McGuinness: As with all schools funded under Local Management of Schools (LMS) arrangements the funding made available to a Grant Maintained Integrated (GMI) school is unhypothecated and thus it is a matter for the Board of Governors of each school to determine how much it spends on staffing, maintenance etc.. GMI schools have additional responsibilities compared to their counterparts in the controlled and maintained sectors and these result in higher costs. The funding arrangements include additional resources to enable them to meet these additional responsibilities. Schools may also transform to Controlled Integrated (CI) status. Insofar as LMS is concerned, controlled integrated schools are treated exactly the same as other controlled or maintained schools. There would be no material benefit as far as capital costs are concerned for controlled schools which transform to either CI or GMI status. Arrangements for capital costs for CI schools would remain unchanged, whereas the only change for GMI schools would be that responsibility for expenditure of a capital nature would transfer from the education and library board to the trustees or Board of Governors of the new GMI school. Any such expenditure that is approved by the Department of Education would be eligible for capital grant at 100% All grant-aided schools are required to follow the statutory curricular and other educational requirements. Finally, since 1997/98 a small amount of funding has been secured annually to assist schools with the additional requirements that the transformation process produces. Healthier Menus Mr Mark Robinson asked the Minister of Education to detail the timescale and costs associated with his plans to introduce healthier menus in schools. (AQW 1246/01) Mr McGuinness: I launched a consultation document on the introduction of new compulsory standards for school meals on 12 December 2001. The consultation period ends on 8 February 2002. The document envisages that the new standards and good practice guidance will be implemented from 1 September 2002, but views have been sought as to whether this timetable is reasonable. It will be essential that catering staff are trained to ensure successful implementation of the standards. I have therefore earmarked a budget of £250k to assist with the training of catering staff. I do not anticipate any addition to the cost of a school meal as a direct result of the implementation of healthier menus. Applications for Enrolment The Lord Kilclooney asked the Minister of Education to detail the number of applications that were (a) received; and (b) not accepted for enrolment in first year in September 2001, in each of the following schools (i) Down High School; (ii) Saintfield High School; and (iii) Regent House Grammar School. (AQW 1285/01) Mr McGuinness: The information requested is as follows: School Applications to Form 1 Applications not accepted September 2001 Down High School 149 20 Saintfield High School 87 22 Regent House Grammar School 239 27 School Enrolment : Strangford Constituency The Lord Kilclooney asked the Minister of Education how many pupils were enrolled at each secondary and grammar school in the Strangford Constituency for the academic years beginning (i) September 2001; and (ii) September 1996. (AQW 1286/01) Mr McGuinness: The number of pupils enrolled at each secondary and grammar school in the Strangford Constituency in the school years 2001/02 and 1996/97 were as follows: School Name: Enrolment 2001/02 1996/97 Comber High School 361 416 Dundonald High School 607 609 Glastry College, 586 531 Lagan College 1013 948 Movilla High School, 873 858 Saintfield High School 336 326 St Columba’s High School, Portaferry 280 345 Strangford Integrated College 416 N/A Scrabo High School N/A 283 Regent House Grammar School, 1449 1441 School Enrollment : Strangford Constituency The Lord Kilclooney asked the Minister of Education how many pupils were enrolled at each primary school in the Strangford Constituency for the academic years beginning (i) September 2001; and (ii) September 1996. (AQW 1287/01) Mr McGuinness: The number of pupils enrolled at each primary school in the Strangford Constituency in the school years 2001/02 and 1996/97 were as follows: School Name: Enrolment 2001/02 1996/97 Abbey Primary School, Newtownards 584 603 Alexander Dickson Primary School, Ballygowan 194 219 Andrews Memorial Primary School, Comber 436 522 Ballycloughan Primary School, Saintfield 68 84 Ballykeigle Primary School, Comber 44 53 Ballywalter Primary School 178 165 Brooklands Primary School, Dundonald 602 583 Carrickmannon Primary School, Ballygowan 94 80 Carrowdore Primary School 150 137 Carryduff Primary School 257 315 Castle Gardens Primary School, Newtownards 357 419 Comber Primary School 340 388 Darragh Cross Primary School, Saintfield 91 86 Derryboy Primary School, Crossgar 60 81 Dundonald Primary School 603 587 Greyabbey Primary School 73 69 Killinchy Primary School 255 240 Killyleagh Primary School 116 140 Kircubbin IntegratedPrimary School 107 79 Kirkistown Primary School 60 58 Londonderry Primary School, Newtownards 280 305 Loughries Primary School, Newtownards 81 83 Moneyrea Primary School 140 143 Newtownards Model Primary School 391 400 O’Neill Memorial Primary School, Belfast 24 43 Portaferry Integrated Primary School 87 48 Portavogie Primary School 134 133 Regent House Preparatory Department 159 161 St Finian’s Primary School, Newtownards 117 144 St Joseph’s Primary School, Carryduff 773 653 St Mary’s Primary School, Comber 36 31 St Mary’s Primary School, Ballygowan 30 50 St Mary’s Primary School, Killyleagh 134 137 St Mary’s Primary School, Kircubbin 158 211 St Mary’s Primary School, Portaferry 246 277 St Patrick’s Primary School, Ballygalget 108 112 Victoria Primary School, Newtownards 559 572 Victoria Primary School, Ballyhalbert 119 101 West Winds Primary School, Newtownards 156 167 Enrolement at Primary Schools : South Eastern Education and Library Board The Lord Kilclooney asked the Minister of Education to outline (a) the five primary schools in the South Eastern Education and Library Board area which had the smallest enrolment totals at the beginning of the academic year September 2001; and (b) the enrolment totals of each of these primary schools. (AQW 1288/01) Mr McGuinness: The five primary schools in the South-Eastern Education and Library Board area with the smallest enrolment totals in the 2001/02 school year are: School Name: Enrolment @ October 2001 Drumbo Primary School, Lisburn 22 Downshire Primary School, Dundrum 23 O’Neill Memorial Primary School, Belfast 24 Groomsport Primary School, Bangor 24 Guiness Primary School, Ballynahinch 27 Standards in Education Mr Mark Robinson asked the Minister of Education how he plans to use information on examination performance to improve standards in education. (AQW 1290/01) Mr McGuinness: The setting of targets at individual school level is an important part of the strategy to raise standards and improve school performance. All schools are required to set targets annually in certain key areas, including examination performance, and to monitor progress towards them. To assist them in this process, my Department provides schools, each year, with aggregated data on performance to enable them to compare their own performance with that of other, similar schools. Performance in Mathematics Mr Ken Robinson asked the Minister of Education if he has any plans to improve pupil performances in mathematics at secondary school level; and to make a statement. (AQW 1333/01) Mr McGuinness: The strategy for the promotion of numeracy provides the focus for driving up further the standards being achieved by pupils in all schools. A review of the strategy, and how it can be strengthened and developed further, is being carried out by my officials, in consultation with the Boards and CCMS. Threshold Assessment Mr Tom Hamilton asked the Minister of Education to outline (a) the procedures which are in place for assessing teachers' threshold pay; (b) the systems in place to ensure parity of treatment; and (c) any variation in these procedures or systems for assessing teachers' threshold pay. (AQW 1335/01) Mr McGuinness: (a) All applications for threshold assessment are assessed by the school Principal and validated by independent external assessors to ensure fairness and consistency in the treatment of all applications. Unsuccessful applicants have a right of appeal. (b) All Principals are trained by the Regional Training Unit, which also trains and accredits the external assessors. The assessors’ work is subject to moderation by their Lead Assessors and the Regional Manager, and to monitoring and evaluation by a Quality Assurance Team. (c) These procedures are applied consistently across all schools. For a small number of teachers employed in non-school settings, their line manager completes the assessments, which are then validated by the external assessors. Burns Report Mr Tom Hamilton asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to AQW 1284/01, to detail (a) the name of the working groups which are to be established; (b) the number of officials for each working group; (c) the remit of each working group; (d) the date on which they are to be established; and (e) to identify any external advisers who are to be co-opted or consulted within these working groups. (AQW 1444/01) Mr McGuinness: The arrangements for the establishment of working groups are still under consideration. No decisions have yet been taken on the remit of each working group or the number of officials who will be involved. There are no plans at present to co-opt or consult with any external advisers. Classroom Assistants Mr John Dallat asked the Minister of Education to outline his policies for the enhancement of classroom assistants in terms of (a) salary; (b) training; and (c) status within the education system. (AQO 568/01) Mr McGuinness: I fully recognise and value the important contribution classroom assistants make to children’s education. However, the terms and conditions of service of classroom assistants are a matter for the employing authorities. Neutrality of Schools Ms Pauline Armitage asked the Minister of Education what measures he is taking to ensure places of education are seen as neutral. (AQO 577/01) Mr McGuinness: Schools should be seen by the community as being above political or sectarian controversy. They should be havens where all our young people can feel safe, confident, and able to concentrate on their education. I have missed no opportunity to convey this message in response to the all too many attacks on schools and children in the past year. Child Protection Joint Working Group Ms Sue Ramsey asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to the meeting of the North-South Ministerial Council in education sectoral format, what measures will be put in place to improve the provision of child protection. (AQO 585/01) Mr McGuinness: The Child Protection Joint Working Group established under the auspices of the North-South Ministerial Council has the remit of developing proposals, in consultation as necessary with other British and Irish Government Departments, to establish a confidential mechanism across both islands for the reciprocal identification of people who are considered to be unsuitable to work with children and young people. Therefore, any proposals we might bring forward, in due course, will require separate but complementary legislation North and South. Text Books Mr Edwin Poots asked the Minister of Education to detail those text books that have been added to the history curriculum in this academic year. (AQO 561/01) Mr McGuinness: My Department does not specify particular text books or resources for use in schools in delivering the curriculum. The choice of books and teaching resources is a matter for the Principal and the Board of Governors of each individual school. Noise Pollution : Effects on Educational Attainment Mr Conor Murphy asked the Minister of Education if he will take account of recent findings on the impact of chronic aircraft noise on pupil attainment as outlined in a report by Mary Haines entitled 'Follow-up study of effects of chronic aircraft noise exposure on child stress responses and cognitions'. (AQO 594/01) Mr McGuinness: This study, carried out in West London schools, was one of a series conducted by a team from the University of London about the effects of chronic high levels of noise around international airports. It found that greater aircraft noise exposure produced higher levels of annoyance among pupils and was associated with poorer reading performance on difficult items on a standard reading test. While none of our schools would be exposed to aircraft noise levels similar to those of Heathrow, I will be taking this research into account in any future decisions about the siting of new schools in proximity to airports. Statements of Special Educational Needs Ms Patricia Lewsley asked the Minister of Education what measures he will put in place to ease the transition from primary to post-primary schools for those children who have been statemented. (AQO 559/01) Mr McGuinness: At transfer age children with statements of special educational needs must have their statements amended to specify the secondary school to be attended. The choice of school is discussed with the parents at the annual review meeting which takes place around the same time as those with parents of other children of transfer age. Updated advice is obtained in order to assist the discussion. Where parents disagree with an Education and Library Board’s final decision, they can appeal to the local Special Educational Needs Tribunal. I am not aware of any particular problems associated with this procedure. Schools Curriculum Mr John Kelly asked the Minister of Education what protocol his Department applies to the vetting of methodologies and resources used with children, particularly special needs children and other vulnerable groups; and to make a statement. (AQO 573/01) Mr McGuinness: The Council for the Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment is responsible for devising the curriculum schools should follow. Schools themselves are responsible for deciding the teaching methods used to deliver the curriculum. My Department’s Inspectorate assesses the effectiveness of the teaching methods used in schools through the inspection process. In recent years inspections have included an evaluation of the effectiveness and quality of provision for children with special educational needs. Post Primary Education Mr Gerry McHugh asked the Minister of Education how he proposes to address a form of selection at 11 years of age which would avoid the same weaknesses that exist in the current system.[R] (AQO 592/01) Mr McGuinness: The weaknesses in the current arrangements for post-primary education are unacceptable and cannot be resolved by any other form of academic selection. The Burns Report has been published for consultation and I encourage everyone to consider it carefully and to submit their views on its proposals, or to identify alternative approaches. I will consider carefully all the comments submitted and in making decisions about the future arrangements my focus will be on ensuring fairness for all children, raising standards and creating a modern education system for a modern age. Re-Employment of Retired Teachers Mr Ken Robinson asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to AQW 651/01, why it has been necessary to employ 1,334 retired teachers in primary and post-primary schools in the 2000-01 school year. (AQO 556/01) Mr McGuinness: The Department does not hold details of the reasons why retired teachers are employed nor is the information collated by the Education and Library Boards. Programmes of Study for Technology and Design at Key Stage 3 Mr Billy Armstrong asked the Minister of Education what measures he proposes to take to develop engineering as a subject in secondary schools. (AQO 564/01) Mr McGuinness: The current curriculum contains basic elements of engineering in the compulsory Programmes of Study for Technology and Design at Key Stage 3 and for Science at Key Stages 3 and 4. My Department’s most recent approval of qualifications circular also offers schools the opportunity to prepare pupils for a Part One GNVQ in Engineering and in addition, the Northern Ireland Business Education Partnership is also promoting engineering through its sponsorship of a number of programmes. The current review of the Curriculum includes a proposal to provide a specific programme for Employability as a statutory requirement for all young people in Key Stages 3 and 4. One of the objectives of the review is to encourage pupils to develop the skills and qualities which they will need for work. There has been (and will continue to be) widespread consultation with employers to ensure that their needs are taken into account in a revised curriculum. Student Enrolments Dr Esmond Birnie asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to provide a breakdown of student enrolments in each further and higher education institute by (a) age; (b) gender; (c) religious background; and (d) other section 75 categories, in each of the last 5 years. (AQW 1153/01) The Minister for Employment and Learning (Ms Hanna): Information regarding student enrolments for the 2001/02 academic year will not be available until April 2002. I have arranged for tables detailing a breakdown of student enrolments in further & higher education in each given academic year from the 1996/97 – 2000/01 academic years to be placed in the Assembly library for your information. Information on political opinion and sexual orientation is not collected for either higher or further education students; information on marital status or dependants is not collected at present for higher education students. Student Support Dr Esmond Birnie asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to detail any correspondence received in relation to the decision to retain the current system of student tuition fees as outlined in the recent review of student finance. (AQW 1154/01) Ms Hanna: As Minister, I receive considerable correspondence in respect of student support, mainly seeking information. In relation to the current system of student tuition fees I have received petitions from two Student Unions and a small number of individual comments. Student Enrolments Dr Esmond Birnie asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to detail the number of student enrolments in each further and higher education institute, on a full-time and part-time basis, for undergraduate and postgraduate courses, in each of the last 3 years. (AQW 1155/01) Ms Hanna: Information regarding student enrolments for the 2001-02 academic year will not be available until April 2002. The following tables set out the information requested in each academic year from 1998/99 – 2000/01.
Note: figures relate to a snapshot of enrolments at 1st November 2000.
Note: figures relate to a snapshot of enrolments at 1st November 1999.
Note: figures relate to a snapshot of enrolments at 1st November 1998. Participation Rates in Further and Higher Education Dr Esmond Birnie asked the Minister for Employment and Learning if she will be producing a response to the University of Ulster report 'Participation Rates in Further and Higher Education'. (AQW 1282/01) Ms Hanna: I do not propose to produce a response to the University of Ulster report. It will be considered in conjunction with other sources of relevant information. Interface Europe Ltd Dr Dara O'Hagan asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to detail any funding made available to Interface Europe Ltd, Craigavon for training purposes over the past two years. (AQW 1355/01) Ms Hanna: Interface Europe Ltd has not received any funding for training through DEL’s Jobskills, New Deal or Worktrack programmes. Enterprise, Trade and Investment Unemployment Statistics : Limavady Mr David McClarty asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment to detail the unemployment figures for Limavady over the last 3 years and what assessment he has made in respect of these figures. (AQW 1171/01) The Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment (Sir Reg Empey): Unemployment statistics at District Council level are only available from the claimant count. Details of claimant count unemployment in Limavady Borough Council and a comparison with Northern Ireland as a whole can be found in Table 1 overleaf. The unemployment figure for Limavady, whilst higher than for Northern Ireland as a whole, has fallen at a similar rate. My Department, through IDB and LEDU, and, when it is established, the new economic development agency Invest Northern Ireland, will continue to work with companies and with the Borough Council and local enterprise agencies to promote further economic activity and employment in the area. Table 1 Number and rate of claimant count unemployed in Limavady Borough Council and Northern Ireland.
Critical Care Register Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment to detail (a) the number of consumers who are on NIE's Medical Care Register; (b) the number of generators supplied by NIE; and (c) contingency plans in place where demand outstrips the supply of generators to individuals on the Medical Care Register. (AQW 1211/01) Sir Reg Empey: NIE has advised that there are currently some 3,000 customers on the company’s Critical Care Register. NIE uses the Register to maintain regular contact with Critical Care customers affected by planned and unplanned power outages. The main aim of the scheme, which operates 24 hours a day 365 days a year, is to provide customers with accurate and timely information about the causes of power interruptions and the likely restoration times and to discuss action which may be required to enable customers to cope with the effects of the disruptions. The vast majority of power interruptions can be managed effectively by this close personal liaison between individual customers and NIE. On occasions NIE, following discussions with the local health agencies, may agree with customers that further assistance in the form of priority restoration action or the provision of small mobile generators is required. A total of 45 portable generators held at the 13 Customer Service Centres across Northern Ireland is available for immediate deployment which are supplemented, when required, by a further stock of 40 generators held and managed centrally. For very severe weather events contingency agreements are in place with local and national suppliers for the provision of additional generators on a hire basis. In an average week, NIE supply 5-15 generators across Northern Ireland for typically 3-6 hours duration. Planning Policy Statement 6 (PPS6) Mr David McClarty asked the Minister of the Environment if he has any plans to encourage the renovation and conversion of existing buildings within East Londonderry as opposed to new build. (AQW 1092/01) The Minister of the Environment (Mr Foster): My Department’s Planning Policy Statement 6 (PPS6) entitled ‘Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage’ provides guidance on this matter. Policy BH 15 of PPS6 states that the Department wishes to encourage the re-use of existing buildings by sympathetic renovation or conversion for a range of appropriate uses, including tourism or recreation, small scale employment or new rural enterprises. The policy has general application throughout Northern Ireland, and is not specific to one particular locality, such as East Londonderry. The Regional Development Strategy for Northern Ireland 2025, recently formulated by the Department for Regional Development, supports at Strategic Planning Guideline (ENV 3.5) the retention of groups of traditional buildings in the landscape and the restoration and continued use of vernacular houses. The Department for Regional Development will be preparing a Planning Policy Statement on the Countryside. This will translate this policy guidance into operational planning policy which will form the basis of consideration of relevant planning applications. Planning (General Development) Order 1993 Mr Mark Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment what advice he issues to district councils on the structure of public consultation regarding planning applications for (a) waste management facilities; and (b) recycling facilities. (AQW 1161/01) Mr Foster: Under Article 15 of the Planning (General Development) Order 1993, the Department is required to consult with relevant district councils on planning applications in their area, and take into account representations made by that council. However, the councils do not have a direct role in consulting the public on such matters. The Department does this directly through advertisement in local newspapers and by neighbour notification. Planning Applications : Small Extensions Mr Jim Shannon asked the Minister of the Environment how many planning applications for small extensions to houses have been received for each of the last 3 years. (AQW 1165/01) Mr Foster: Domestic extensions in Planning Service’s database include Domestic Garages and Domestic Outbuildings, which include pigeon lofts. Based on this definition, details of the number of ‘ Domestic Extensions’ over the last 3 years are set out below: Year Extensions 1999 5,3232000 4,853 2001 5,424
Total 15,600 Areas of Townscape Character Mr David McClarty asked the Minister of the Environment what steps he is taking to encourage the use of period detailing in the design of (i) new buildings and (ii) replacement buildings in areas of unique townscape character. (AQW 1170/01) Mr Foster: ‘Areas of Townscape Character’ are designated because they have an identifiable character which is distinguishable from surrounding development through a combination of historical context, urban grain, street pattern, building blocks, height and massing, architectural style, building lines, views, public space, patterns of movement, landscape, topography and the nature of uses and activities. Architectural style is only one of the range of criteria associated with such designations. Therefore, the use of period detailing in a new proposal may not necessarily address the identified character of an Area of Townscape Character. It is also important to leave room for individual creative expression, and to address contemporary concerns in architecture. While my Department does not wish to be too prescriptive about ‘period detailing’ in new and replacement proposals, it will continue to ensure that whatever particular character is identified in an Area of Townscape Character, will be reflected and enhanced in the consideration of development proposals. High Visibility Sites Mr David McClarty asked the Minister of the Environment what plans he has to limit development and exploitation on high visibility sites in scenic locations. (AQW 1173/01) Mr Foster: My Department is aware of the importance of protecting our scenic areas from inappropriate development, including visually prominent buildings, and has a number of policies in place to control such development and to protect such areas ‘A Planning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland’ (PSRNI) is the main Policy Document for the control of development in the countryside. Policy DES 4, which relates to Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONBs), states that such areas are not only of high scenic quality but often of wildlife importance and rich in both cultural and architectural heritage. The objectives of an AONB designation are to conserve/enhance the natural beauty or amenity of the area and its wildlife, while ensuring that public access is provided. Countryside Assessments, which are produced as part of my Department’s Development Plan process, assist in the consideration of each designated AONB to identify distinctive local landscape character types and their potential for protection, enhancement or limited development. My Department has published the Northern Ireland Landscape Character Assessment 2000 which identified 130 landscape character areas throughout the region. This document provides a valuable database to inform the development of planning policies in development plans. Policy DES 5 of the PSRNI stipulates that planning permission will be granted for the erection of a building on a site which can be visually integrated into the landscape ensuring that it does not spoil any scenic aspect or detract from the visual appearance of the countryside. The policy does go on to state that a new building will not be acceptable if, when viewed from surrounding vantage points, it occupies a prominent, skyline or, top of slope/ridge location. Vernacular Architecture : East Londonderry Mr David McClarty asked the Minister of the Environment what plans he has to promote vernacular architecture for tourism development within East Londonderry. (AQW 1174/01) Mr Foster: Design principles for all types of development, including tourism-related developments, are set out in "A Planning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland". This guidance relates to developments both in urban or rural settings. In the countryside generally and particularly in designated Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty, developers and architects are encouraged to design new buildings that respect, and where appropriate, reflect, the traditional architectural styles. In addition, where appropriate, in towns, villages and the open countryside, my Department positively encourages the re-use of vernacular buildings for appropriate purposes, including those related to tourism, as a means of contributing to sustainable development and encouraging social and economic regeneration. Such buildings contribute directly to tourism, as they are suitable for renovation to self catering accommodation. Guidance on this matter is contained in Chapter 9 of Planning Policy Statement 6 ‘Planning and the Built Heritage’. My Department’s Environment and Heritage Service co-ordinates European Heritage Open Days – a Council of Europe initiative, which increases appreciation, and understanding of the built heritage through free-access visits to historic monuments and buildings throughout Northern Ireland. This has wide appeal for locals and tourists alike. As part of the programme for European Heritage Open Days 2002, theEnvironment and Heritage Service will be working with the Foyle Civic Trust to increase visitation to vernacular buildings within the East Londonderry area. The Member will be aware that my Department has recently commenced work on the preparation of the Northern Area Plan. Any need to enhance existing policies, in response to particular local needs in the Plan Area, can be considered in the context of the new Plan. Knockagh Road, Carrickfergus Mr David Hilditch asked the Minister of the Environment, pursuant to AQW 3034/00 and AQW 3035/00, to detail what progress has been made to stop illegal dumping on the Knockagh Road, Carrickfergus. (AQW 1198/01) Mr Foster: Further to my previous replies, I can confirm that Planning officials have now sought the advice of the Environment & Heritage Service’s Water Quality Unit, and the Department for Regional Development’s Roads Service, in relation to the illegal dumping being carried out at the Knockagh Road, Carrickfergus. Investigations have also been undertaken to establish the ownership of the land in question, and the whereabouts of the landowners. Attempts to resolve the matter by negotiation and agreement have proved unsuccessful, and formal enforcement notices will be served on the landowners this week, requiring the removal of waste materials and the restoration of the site. Cavehill Bowling and Lawn Tennis Club Mr Gerry Kelly asked the Minister of the Environment to detail any plans to erect a telecommunications mast on the grounds of Cavehill Bowling and Lawn Tennis Club, on the North Circular Road and 642-644 Antrim Road. (AQW 1207/01) Mr Foster: My Department received an application for ‘Prior Approval’ determination on behalf of Hutchinson 3G UK Ltd on 2 November 2001, in respect of the erection of telecommunication apparatus at the Cavehill Bowling and Lawn Tennis Club. Prior approval was refused on 14 December 2001. My Department has received no further applications to date. As regards 642-644 Antrim Road, Belfast, my Department received an application for ‘Prior Approval’ determination on behalf of BT Cellnet Ltd on 6 September 2001. My Department confirmed ‘Prior approval’ on 1 November 2001. My Department has received no further applications to date. Special Protection Area Mr Ken Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment if he has any plans to convene a meeting with interested groups around Larne Lough to review and discuss the future of its special protection areas (SPA); and to make a statement. (AQW 1208/01) Mr Foster: I have no current plans to meet with interested groups concerning Larne Lough’s designation as a Special Protection Area. I am aware that there has been a number of contacts in recent years between my officials in Environment and Heritage Service and local groups including the Friends of Larne Lough, concerning a range of environmental matters. I understand that my officials have found these meetings to be positive and helpful in fostering an awareness of the importance of the conservation interests at Larne Lough. Badger Sett, Cloughey Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment, pursuant to AQW 866/01 and AQW 867/01, to detail how the Environment and Heritage Service intends to protect the badger sett. (AQW 1256/01) Mr Foster: The badger sett on the development site at Cloughey is protected by Article 10 of the Wildlife (Northern Ireland) Order 1985. Under that Article, it is an offence to kill or injure a badger, or to disturb a badger whilst it is in its sett, or to damage, destroy or obstruct access to a badger sett. Officials of the Environment and Heritage Service have informed the developer of his legal obligations and have suggested measures that he should take in order to comply with the law. These measures include the construction of a reinforced concrete deck which completely bridges the badger sett and is designed to carry all access traffic and services into the site. The measures also include a requirement that no development or disturbance of the ground surface take place within 25 metres of the badger sett entrances and that any fencing on site allows for passage of the badgers to and from their foraging areas. EHS will monitor the development, but enforcement would be a matter for the Police Service. Disposal of Cars Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment to detail (a) the relevant European legislation which will apply to the disposal of cars after 1 April 2002; and (b) any financial assistance available for local district councils to implement the new legislation. (AQW 1274/01) Mr Foster: In relation to (a), the relevant European legislation is the EC End of Life Vehicles (ELV) Directive (2000/53/EC). The Directive aims to reduce the amount of waste arising from scrapped vehicles. All Member States are required to transpose the Directive into national legislation by 21 April 2002. It is unlikely that the UK will be in a position to introduce legislation implementing the Directive by the due date. However, a public consultation has already taken place in Northern Ireland as part of the UK exercise carried out in August 2001. In light of the responses to the consultation document, discussions are continuing within Whitehall, led by the Department of Trade and Industry, to determine the best legislative and implementation options. My officials are closely involved in those discussions, including the costs in implementing the Directive. In relation to (b), I have no plans at present to provide any additional financial assistance to local district councils for this purpose. It is not expected that implementation of the Directive will impose any new obligations on District Councils. However, concerns have been expressed that, depending on final decisions on implementation, there could be an increase in abandoned cars that could lead to additional costs for Councils. It is also likely that the costs of disposal will increase. I will bear the funding issue in mind as implementation options and associated costs become clearer. Disposal of Cars Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment to detail, by district council area, the number of cars which have been disposed of by local district councils in each year of the past 5 years. (AQW 1275/01) Mr Foster: The information sought is not held centrally by my Department and therefore I am unable to provide the information requested. Disposal of Abandoned Cars Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment to detail (a) the cost per unit that local district councils presently incur through the disposal of abandoned cars; and (b) the estimated future cost per unit following the implementation of new legislation on 1 April 2002. (AQW 1276/01) Mr Foster: The information sought at (a) is not held centrally by my Department and therefore I am unable to provide the information requested. In relation to (b), I refer the Member to the answer to AQW 1274/01. The future cost of disposal is unknown but it is likely to increase in relation to existing costs. The legislation to implement the Directive will be subject to public consultation; this will include publication of a regulatory impact assessment that will address associated costs. Disposal of Fridges and Freezers Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment, pursuant to AQWs 928/01, 929/01 and 930/01, to detail (a) the timescale for the publication of guidelines on the disposal of fridges and freezers for local district councils in light of EC Regulations 2037/2000; and (b) if financial assistance will be provided to local district councils to comply with these regulations. (AQW 1277/01) Mr Foster: (a) My officials have prepared draft guidance on the storage of waste refrigeration units awaiting disposal. This guidance has now been issued to all Councils for consideration. (b) I am aware of the difficulties caused by the EC decision to extend the Regulation on Ozone Depleting Substances to the disposal of domestic refrigeration equipment. I also appreciate that the necessary technology to deal with disposal, in line with the requirements of the Regulation, is not presently available anywhere in the UK or the Republic of Ireland. Storage is therefore the only short-term option. I am also aware that storage and disposal of these units will have operational and cost implications for District Councils. My officials have been working to estimate the quantity of fridges involved and identify the likely additional financial burden which might be faced by the local authorities. At this preliminary stage it is estimated that the number of units likely to be dealt with in Northern Ireland may be in the range of 60,000/80,000 per annum. This figure may change when more detailed information becomes available. Unfortunately there are no specific funds earmarked for this purpose in the DOE budgets for this year or next. However I shall do all that I can to secure some financial assistance for Councils, bidding to DFP as necessary and taking account of the levels of assistance being made available in GB. Hospitality : December 2001 Mr David Hilditch asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel to detail (a) the cost of and (b) to whom he is providing hospitality during the month of December 2001. (AQW 1066/01) The Minister of Finance and Personnel (Dr Farren): A Christmas reception was hosted by the Minister of Finance and Personnel for Departmental officials and the invitation was extended to the Committee for Finance and Personnel. The total cost of the event was £735. PEACE II Operational Programme Mr Derek Hussey asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel to detail the areas of responsibility for each of the Peace II intermediary funding bodies. (AQW 1206/01) Dr Farren: Under the PEACE II Operational Programme, 13 areas of activity in Northern Ireland and 3 areas of cross-border activity in Northern Ireland and the Border Region of Ireland have been identified for administration/management by IFBs. Overall IFBs will be responsible for almost £120 million of Programme funds. The attached table details the Areas of Activity under the PEACE II Programme designated for delivery by IFBs, the amounts of money involved, and the organisations/consortia successful in the open tendering exercise.
Review of Government Office Accommodation Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel when he expects to receive the final report on the review of government office accommodation. (AQO 542/01) Dr Farren: It is anticipated that the Consultant’s Final Report will be submitted to the Department by the end of April 2002. Public Accounts Committee/Comptroller and Auditor General Mr Tom Hamilton asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel if he has had occasion to request a Department to comply more fully with recommendations from the Public Accounts Committee or the Comptroller and Auditor General. (AQO 563/01) Dr Farren: I can confirm that neither I or my predecessor has had to make such a request. My Officials work closely with those Departments that are the subject of PAC Reports to produce Memoranda of Reply. As part of that process they will have had occasion to request that Departments comply more fully with PAC recommendations than may have been envisaged. My Department will continue to ensure that PAC recommendations are addressed as fully as possible. Needs and Effectiveness Review Mr Eugene McMenamin asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what progress has been made on the Needs and Effectiveness Review; and to make a statement. (AQO 582/01) Dr Farren: The Executive agreed five evaluations for the review of expenditure covering the areas of Health and Personal Social Services, Education, Housing, Training and Vocational Education, and Financial Assistance to Industry. An additional needs and effectiveness evaluation covering the programmes of the Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure has also been initiated. My officials continue to work with colleagues in the Economic Policy Unit (OFMDFM) and relevant departments to examine needs and expenditure in Northern Ireland and the extent to which current policies are being delivered effectively. Final reports on the effectiveness evaluations are due by the end of May 2002. Health, Social Services and Public Safety Food Standards Agency Mrs Iris Robinson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety, in relation to the Food Standards Agency tests on scallop fisheries for amnesic and diarrhetic shellfish poisoning, what assessment can she make in comparing her tests with those carried out in the UK and Europe. (AQW 1103/01) The Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (Ms de Brún): The reference laboratory for marine biotoxins, the Fisheries Research Services (FRS) in Aberdeen, organises regular meetings of all laboratories in Great Britain and here which undertake statutory testing for amnesic and diarrhetic shellfish poisoning. Part of the purpose of such meetings is to discuss the toxin test methods used, with the aim being to ensure a consistent approach to testing in Great Britain and here. As part of its duties, FRS also takes part in discussions on methodology at a European level. Eagraíonn an tsaotharlann tagartha le haghaigh bitocsainí mara, na Seirbhísí Taighde Iascaigh STI in Obar Dheathain cruinnithe rialta gach saotharlainne sa Bhreatain Mhór agus anseo a thugann faoi tástáil reachtúil ar nimhiú aimnéiseach agus buinní iasc sliogach. Cuid de chuspóir na gcruinnithe seo is ea modhanna tastála tocsaine a úsáidtear, a bhfuil sé mar aidhm acu chur chuige seasmhach i dtaobh tástála sa Bhreatain Mhór agus anseo. Mar chuid dá dhualgais glacann STI páirt i bplé ar mhodheolaíocht ar leibhéal Eorpach. Ratio of Doctors per 100 Hospital Beds Mr Mark Robinson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what is the current ratio of doctors per 100 beds in NHS hospitals in each Health Board area. (AQW 1114/01) Ms de Brún: The information requested is detailed in the table below. Ratio of doctors1 per 100 hospital beds – March 2001
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||